16 Best Mattresses Reviewed (2022): Floyd, Allswell & More

How does this mattress compare to other mattresses you’ve slept on?

The mattress was extremely comfortable—firm, body-conforming, and had a sense of evenness and stability that was very soothing and calming. Without doubt I felt cool on the mattress—or at least I did not feel overheated—though I do concede I was sleeping in a fairly cool bedroom at the time. I suspect the mattress would stand up to the test of time and I did, indeed, get the sense that body heat was being propelled away as I slept.

Would you buy from this mattress brand again?

I would. The support was solid, the shape a winner, and it definitely felt as if my body was cooler than usual and extremely comfortable.

Reviewer: Zoë Sessums, digital design writer

What stands out about this mattress brand to you?

I feel like Casper was the original mattress-in-a-box brand, so I trust its authority in the space. Casper regularly launches new products and models, so it seems like it is excited about evolving.

What mattress do you have? 

Casper Nova Hybrid

What do you love about this mattress?

First off, this mattress looks really nice—the details in the color and materials make it stand out right out of the box. It’s firm without feeling stiff, it’s soft without making you sink—it’s that Goldilocks perfection.

If you could change anything about it, what would it be?

I would firm up the mattress if I could make any changes.

How does this mattress compare to other mattresses you’ve slept on?

This mattress is a lot softer and squishier than other mattresses I’ve slept on in recent years. It definitely feels luxurious and is nice to lounge around on, but it’s often a tad bit soft for night after night of sleep.

Would you buy from this mattress brand again?

I would buy from Casper, but I would try out a different model.

Reviewer: Zoë Sessums, digital design writer

What stands out about this mattress brand to you?

I was compelled by the eco-friendly aspects—Birch’s products are free of any polyurethane-based foams and harsh chemicals. I’m always interested in staying informed about mattress companies that have sustainably sourced materials and practices.

What mattress do you have?

Birch Natural Mattress in full. 

What do you love about this mattress?

First off, this mattress looks really nice—the details in the color and materials made it stand out right out of the box. It’s firm but doesn’t feel stiff and soft without making you sink—it’s that Goldilocks perfection.

If you could change anything about it, what would it be?

I have no complaints!

How does this mattress compare to other mattresses you’ve slept on?

I think the construction is very quality-focused—it feels like it has more durability than some other mattresses I’ve bought and slept on.

Would you buy from this mattress brand again?

I would. I trust the quality of its products.

Reviewer: Elise Portale, social media manager

What stands out about this mattress brand to you?

It’s your classic “bed in a box” mattress, which is always a real treat, if you ask me. When I bought it, I remember wanting an upgrade from my previous spring mattress, but the direct-to-consumer mattresses from all of my favorite podcast ads were still pretty much out of my budget. Tuft & Needle really hit that sweet spot of being a high-quality foam mattress at a more affordable price.